Jackson Carlaw

---

How much time must pass before a new generation Yes?

Boris Johnson has Nicola Sturgeon rejected ' s call for a new independence referendum in 2014, insisting the vote was a "once in A Generation " event. Why do people always have with this sentence, and what does it mean?

Why is this coming now?

The Debate over a second independence referendum has echoed precedent, much of The Debate on The First because you can see both sides of it as setting a useful.

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon wants to keep the British government to give a vote to, because that was the "gold standard" procedure in the year 2014.

Boris Johnson will not say another referendum, and some of Ms Sturgeon's own words from the original campaign, as the reason for the no -.

The Prime Minister 's letter, the rejection of Ms sturgeon's request to her said, "you and your predecessors made a personal promise that 2014 was the independence referendum a 'once in A Generation " vote. The people in Scotland voted decisively to keep the promise of our United Kingdom . "

He has to echo this line when questioned on The Matter , But the SNP insists that times have changed, and The Party has a "vulnerable" mandate for a new referendum.

Who says what?

In Alex Salmond 's Preface, the white paper on independence before the referendum in 2014, the then first minister, said the vote would be a "rare and precious moment in the history of Scotland - a once in A Generation opportunity to chart a better way".

The document went on, there was "no agreement in place for another referendum on independence" and that "only a majority of the votes for" Yes "would give the certainty that Scotland will become independent".

Mr Salmond and his team the record several times in interviews, including, where he said that "from my point of view, this is a once in A Generation , perhaps even a once in a Lifetime opportunity".

His Deputy, Ms sturgeon, used the "life time" phrase, while before the referendum, as three other SNP MSPs before a motion, the ballot, the "Chance of a Lifetime ".

independence supporters claim that Mr Salmond was stating his own view he said Mr. Marr, "it's just my opinion" and The Position of his government bind its successors.

The SNP also points to the additional powers for Holyrood, released two months after the referendum, in which they stated that "nothing in this report prevents Scotland should be an independent country in The Future , the people of Scotland so choose".

How long is A Generation anyway?

If you have a aphid of rhopalosiphum prunifolia family, A Generation , apparently, 4. 7 days.

For the people, an essay for The International society for Genetic genealogy, the length of the average generation decreased seems to be somewhere in The Range of.

But how long a political generation?

This is a bit of a speculation on the length of a piece of string Scotland Office minister Douglas Ross took the shotgun approach to say it should be "30, 40, or 50 Years ," in an interview with the " BBC's Good Morning Scotland programme on Wednesday.

His boss Alister Jack , the Scottish Secretary, had previously proposed that a vote should not take place, while the Ms interference, the life time, which would be based on the average Life Expectancy at least a few more Decades yet.

The Good Friday agreement, seven years is a reasonable gap between referendums

it was suggested that historical examples that might help?

There were 18 years between the two referendums on Scottish devolution in 1979 and 1997. Mr Salmond cited this gap in the Andrew Marr interview, said: "this is what I mean by a political generation".

in the Meantime, it was 41 years between referendums on EU membership in 1975, and in 2016, a distance, the peaks of the interim Scottish Conservative leader Jackson Carlaw .

But switching to a different constitutional setting, stating that it was seven years between border polls on Irish reunification.

The image is actually regulated by law. Obviously, the context of the political history in Northern Ireland is very different than Scotland , But The Deal is that the seven-year scheme has been decided, both by the members and, of course,

it Is only a formulation?

The SNP's claim that it was never their intention to close the door on The Future - why should they? and the sentence was to Express a way is crucial, because they thought the referendum in 2014.

you don't say it was a "personal promise", as the Prime Minister claimed, But the kind of rhetoric that politicians employ Every Day .

the context can be The Key .

For example, Mr. Johnson said. December's parliamentary Election was a " vote - But no one really expected that it is The Last Westminster poll for Decades .

There are only a few topics to look at which Nicola Sturgeon and Boris Johnson , an eye for an eye

The Tories say, expectations are different, for people's decisions - they are designed to pay binary questions, and come up far less often. The Last thing we want, they say, is a "neverendum".

Although in this latter point, there was no lack of people voting, since the Conservatives came to power in 2010 - on the electoral system, on Scottish independence, on the strengthening of skills for the Welsh Assembly, and on the UK's EU-exit.

you Do change things with the time?

The Chief argument, the staff of the SNP for a new referendum is that things have changed significantly since 2014. The Party says, the United Kingdom , the the speech at the time to stay the Scots voted, a part that no longer exists was.

The British EU vote exit, to secure the most important driver of this, in view of the 62%, Remain in Scotland , and there is No campaign insisted was, in the year 2014 that "Scotland enjoys membership in the EU because of our membership of the UK".

The Conservative rebuttal to this would be that the United Kingdom voted as a whole to leave the EU - that was a change, which cannot be justified by the people, and thus, by itself, change a other to.

of course, there are also a number of other votes since the referendum.

In another interview in the year 2014, Mr Salmond, the only circumstances in which you could have said: "a further referendum would be, if you have an additional mandate in the next General elections".

have The SNP come out on top in any Election North of The Border , because then most of the UK were recently under 45% of the Scottish vote in The General Election - a larger share than that of Mr. Johnson ' s victorious Conservatives-far.

If this type of form holds - particularly at the Holyrood by-Election in the year 2021 - the Prime Minister may need a new tag.

scottish independence, nicola sturgeon

Source of news: bbc.com